Steelers' defense tests Colts' uneven offense
Pittsburgh's struggling ground game meets an Indianapolis front that has been vulnerable on the ground.
- Jonathan Taylor: 353 rushing yards, 6 touchdowns
- Aaron Rodgers: 999 passing yards, 7 touchdown passes
- T.J. Watt: 5 sacks in four games
2 min read
By the Keel Stats Research DeskHow this story was writtenReport a correction
Final
Game card: Indianapolis Colts 22, Pittsburgh Steelers 34, with each team's leader
The Indianapolis Colts and Pittsburgh Steelers both enter Week 5 at 2-2, but Sunday, October 11, will put two very different formulas under pressure at Acrisure Stadium. Indianapolis needs Jonathan Taylor to keep its offense on schedule against one of the league's best defenses, while Pittsburgh needs to find enough offense to support its own defense.
Kickoff is at 1:00 PM ET, with an 87% chance of rain that could make ball security and the run game more central. The Colts have produced a 30-13 road win over Washington and a 19-17 home win over Houston, while the Steelers' most recent result was a 27-24 loss at Cleveland.
A defense built to squeeze the passing game
Pittsburgh has been the sharper side of this matchup by efficiency, ranking sixth in defensive EPA allowed per play at -0.059. EPA per play measures the expected points added on each snap, while success rate tracks the share of plays with positive EPA; the Steelers are fourth against the pass and have allowed 225.3 passing yards per game, 12th best in the league.
That is a hard assignment for Daniel Jones and an Indianapolis passing attack averaging 188.5 yards per game, 27th in the NFL. Jones has thrown for 754 yards with four interceptions in four starts, and Josh Downs leads the Colts with 202 receiving yards; T.J. Watt's five sacks give Pittsburgh another way to disrupt an offense that has been far better through the air by efficiency than its raw yardage suggests.
Taylor is the counterweight. His 353 rushing yards and six touchdowns create a direct test for a Steelers front allowing 112.8 rushing yards per game, but Pittsburgh ranks 13th in rush defense by efficiency and has kept opponents to a manageable profile overall.
Pittsburgh's opening on the ground
The Steelers' offense ranks 29th in EPA per play at -0.108 and scores 19.3 points per game, but Indianapolis offers a potential escape route. The Colts rank 30th in rush defense by efficiency and allow 131 rushing yards per game, giving Jaylen Warren's 309 rushing yards a chance to matter even as Pittsburgh's rushing offense sits 26th by efficiency.
Aaron Rodgers has 999 passing yards and seven touchdown passes, with DK Metcalf leading the club at 213 receiving yards. Yet protection remains the urgent concern: Pittsburgh has allowed 3.3 sacks per game, 31st in the league, against a Colts defense that ranks eighth with three sacks per game; DeForest Buckner has four of them.
Indianapolis will be without defensive end Arden Key, and cornerback Charvarius Ward is questionable with a groin injury; the Colts list three players out and four questionable. Pittsburgh has cornerback Jamel Dean out with an ankle injury and Jalen Ramsey questionable with a wrist injury, with four Steelers out and two questionable overall.
The game is at Acrisure Stadium in Pittsburgh at 1:00 PM ET Sunday. Sportsbooks' prices give Pittsburgh a 57% chance to win, compared with 43% for Indianapolis.
Also in this story
Jonathan Taylor RB73.9 rush yds a game8 rush TD2.8 catches a game2026 season · 10 gamesProps
- Aaron Rodgers
QB223.8 pass yds a game15 pass TD6 INT2026 season · 9 gamesProps
Jaylen Warren RB79.9 rush yds a game2 rush TD3.3 catches a game2026 season · 9 gamesProps
Pittsburgh Steelers6–3 2026 seasonNext: at PHI, Sun, Nov 22 · 1:00 PM
More on the Indianapolis Colts
Share this story
Keel Stats every day
The day's numbers as they come out: follow Keel Stats.
From Keel Stats data; every number is checked against our data before publishing.
Comments
Keep it about basketball and football, and keep it civil.
Sign in to join the discussion.
Sign in to Keel Stats
New here? Your first day of Pro is free, no card.
Loading comments…